Review
Premiership
- 7 October 2012
out of the 8 poll choices of course? Things to consider: Prime and peak (best season).
Last edited:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
I don't see a poll option bro
p.s. I know who Gerd will pick.
Fernando Redondo
I didn't really think of Effenberg as a real DMF. I mean there was huge difference between someone like him and Gattusso. Effenberg was a playmaker and more advanced at least at the beginning.
p.s. I know who Gerd will pick.
Fernando Redondo
you hurt our feelings buddy
Don't know what you're talking about Ben, Redondo is definitely a DM, taking by your defintion a DM is supposed to destroy play only or make simple passes?
then i guess we just have a different idea of what a defensive midfielder isamineken22 said:BTW Guardiola was definitely a DM too
yeah..... paulo silva.... where did that come fromKanoute said:oh and btw, lo zio, you meant to say paulo sousa in your fourth paragraph, I guess.
i was just messing with u guys (wich is why i even apologised for sounding like a jerk)... i certainly didn't mean to insult any of ukanoute said:can't really disagree with it (I know you're joking, though). lo zio is one of my favorite posters on the forum and I absolutely don't think he meant to be arrogant by any means, but can't really say that I enjoyed reading his last post (this might be for the first time).
good luck with that!Seems everybody got his own definition of role here and it's really confusing (Like Gerd talking about Wing-backs being Side-backs) We should have some sort of come ground here, otherwise it's like everyone rambling their own way.
i haven't watched much of inter lately, so i can't really tell. however when i referred to him as a dm i was considering his prime (wich imo is the most appropriate moment to judge a player's role)... this is what i do with every player. for instance i also usually refer to maldini as a leftback, even though he played as a cb in his last years... and for the same reason i also consider matthaus as a defensive midfielder (even though he played often as a cb in his last years).amineken said:Also now-a-days Cambiasso doesn't really focus that much on his defensive duties and he's a more of all round player (even more offensive too) do you still consider him as DM?
davids was a bit of a jack of all trades, thanks to his insane energy, but yes, i'd say that in his prime, his main focus was on the defensive aspect in the game.Kanoute said:on another note, seemingly you think that vieira and davids are dmf but they're not mainly focused on defence which is your measure for dmfs as you said above. vieira was very fine at making plays and davids was a very aggresively attacking player when his teams had the possesion.
but a deep-lying playmaker occupies exactly that same spot (just ahead of the defense). it all comes down to how u interpretate your role on the pitch, rather than the portion of the pitch u occupy.Gerd said:IMO Fernando Redondo's position was DMF, but his role was that of some sort of playmaker before the defense.
may i ask u how old are u amineken? if u remember toninho we probably have the same age.
may i ask u how old are u amineken? if u remember toninho we probably have the same age.