FC Barcelona Thread

Can anyone name some players from other clubs who break the rules Barca were banned for?

From what little I've read, other clubs may have done it too but nothing like the scale of Barca, whose management have essentially taken the attitude of 'we should be exempt. We're Barca'. Is that right? others here will no doubt know more about it than me.

I like Barca, always have, and it's undeniable their academy is good for players, but rules have to be universal otherwise you end up with a climate of rent-seeking and even more corruption
 
Good post, zio, as I said it's a very complicated debate and the only solution I can think of is that fathers and kids do what they want. I'm not smarter than this, unfortunately.

Godotelli said:
Can anyone name some players from other clubs who break the rules Barca were banned for?

From what little I've read, other clubs may have done it too but nothing like the scale of Barca, whose management have essentially taken the attitude of 'we should be exempt. We're Barca'. Is that right? others here will no doubt know more about it than me.

I like Barca, always have, and it's undeniable their academy is good for players, but rules have to be universal otherwise you end up with a climate of rent-seeking and even more corruption
Click to expand...

Well, practically all european clubs did break those rules in the last decade. When barcelona was punished, there were about 1.500 youngsters in the exact same situation, according to a study I read back then.

Let's recap a bit how did it happen: FIFA published those rules because they didn't want kids brought to Europe from Africa and Asia in very dangerous situations and be traded as a commodity, as Zio said. A lot of small clubs were signing packs of African or Asian boys, exploiting them for one or two years and then leaving them with nothing on their pockets, literally on the street. That's when FIFA started to think about applying some rules.

By then, Barcelona had created an international system of scouts in many countries and was grabbing the most promising kids from all around the world. Kids from 12 onwards. The contract they sign with the families implies very high levels of services: they are given a house, food, school and all kinds of assistance during the whole contract, which happens to be several years long and there's also money involved. And they are monitored by social services and everything is done according to Spanish laws. Whether this is ethical or not, I really don't know anymore what to think. I leave parents the right to decide what's best for their families. As I said, think of the example of a violinist kid who goes to Salzburg to study in a top musical accademy. Would you deny him the right for that chance?

Due to the excellent conditions of all the system, Barcelona was given an international prize for the youth accademy, acclaimed as the perfect example of how to treat young players.

So, when Fifa suddenly changed the policy about youngsters, it was a clear blow for the Barcelona system, that had been build to cover world ahtletes. Barcelona talked with Fifa, arguing that it was absurd that they couldn't sign players if they had been acclaimed for it, and that the families wanted to go to Barcelona because it was a much better chance than staying at their clubs of origin. Thay asked Fifa to install some kind of Certificate to clubs that assured good conditions for the players.

And while the club and Fifa were talking, Barcelona signed some boys and suddenly an anonymous lawsuit was accepted at Fifa. This came as a surprise for the club. Fifa never told who was behind the lawsuit, but suddenly expanded the claim and Barcelona was asked to let go all of the boys that had been signed in the last 2 years that didn't comply with the new regulation(so they applied the law with retroactivity). This meant a powerful blow to the youth accademy.

Barcelona managers did wrong, probably moved by anger at the whole political turn of the situation. They didn't want to dismantle all those youth teams, arguing that all european clubs had players in the exact same condition, that Barcelona youth accademy was an example according to Fifa and that they had the right to keep those boys. That's what you probably heard, Godotelli. But it's important to know the context.

And then the managers did the biggest mistake of them all: they signed a couple of Corean boys, one of them named Lee is a very promising kid. It's not that Barcelona went to Corea and grabbed him, it's just the opposite, the player was offered to barcelona by their parents.

Barcelona argued that it was the families that went to Barcelona because they wanted to sign, and the response to this by Fifa was the transfer ban.

Up to now, no other club has been punished, and nothing else has been done in order to really preserve the conditions in which young kids are brought to Europe. If the new rules are really better for young kids, we still don't know, there's no evidence for or against it.

But most of all, they ended up punishing kids, which is ironic. It's the mark of mobsters, if you ask me. Punish the club if you want, but if you punish the kids, then you're an hypocrite and an idiot.
 
Last edited:
Question Drekkard or any informed Barcelona fan, is Messi going to be back for El Classico?

Going to the game at the Bernabau.
 
I don't think so, younggun. That was one of the first reactions right after the injury, that he would miss the classico.
Perhaps he's getting better sooner than expected.
 
I haven't heard anything yet and I follow barca pretty closely. I doubt he will be there and if he is II further doubt they will rush him out. Ligament tears mean usually 2 months for professional footballers and he got injured end of September that's 6 weeks till El Classico
 
I was in Madrid but it was a joy to see you lot play on Saturday, so much talent and ability.

Neymar was the best player on the pitch for me, he was phenomenal, I also think he's now the 2nd best player in the world (currently first because leo isnt 100% yet)
 
there are no words to describe this team...

it will go down in history as the best there ever was.

the front 3 players imo are 3 best players in world...

121 goals between them in 2015, let that sink in...
 
CXgRMFAWsAATMrK.jpg
 
I think it wasn't as many as that. But all the kids that couldn't play for the last 18 months and 2 for the first team: Arda Turan and Aleix Vidal. Finally the nightmare for those kids is over.

By the way, 17 kids have gone to other european clubs unregarding the rules that apparently led Barça to be punished. The scandal continues, I just wish that the Corean boy, Lee, can finally play and score at the Bernabeu in the near future.
 
Last edited:
We at The Arsenal are loving Bellerin que crack.:) I was hoping to take Samper next :PRAY: although he made capt. after the other went to Benfica.
 
Arda will play a lot in the upcoming matches, I have high hopes in him. A pitty Espnyol decided to play rugby instead of football, the attitude of the Espanyol goalkeeper was lame. Once Arda clicks with the rest of the team it can be very entertaining.
 
drekkard said:
Arda will play a lot in the upcoming matches, I have high hopes in him. A pitty Espnyol decided to play rugby instead of football, the attitude of the Espanyol goalkeeper was lame. Once Arda clicks with the rest of the team it can be very entertaining.
Click to expand...

Yea, Barca are a bit boring these days ;)
 
I saw the Barça vs atletí game pre-recordeded naturally. Meh, that was barbaric assault on Messi. He deserved to be 8wk (removed) n send back to Brasil . The highlights show a bad tackle but the game proves he was temper before. It was some nasty - nasty stuff ! Barça aren't perfect but they played it safe and could of humiliated Atletí
 
I agree with you on Felipe Luis' tackle.
Not sure about the rest.
Barcelona were the better team, but in the second half Atletico had at least one excellent chance to equalise. If you are that much stronger you should at leat put 2 goal behind you and your opponent.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom