• Note for new users: Please keep your posts English or we will delete them. There's a "No English?" area in our Editing discussion forum for those who prefer writing in their native language.
  • Site maintenance info: We got rid of the "Patches and Option Files" area and moved all threads from 2020 to their corresponding subs in the Editing area. Let me know if you're missing a thread or face any other issues related to this move. /Tom

Which players do you think should be improved in WE9 ??

Status
Not open for further replies.

Interista

Il Capitano
19 August 2003
Bahrain
FC Internazionale
Who do you think is underrated and his stats should be improved in the new WE9 ?? and also who do you think was overrated and should have a stat-drop ?

for me:

Underrated- Robben, Lampard, Belleti, Forlan
Overrated- Diesler, Vieri(should lose speed)
 
Last edited:

mattster12

All-round Bastard
11 April 2005
forlan overated? He shared the golden boot with henry ffs. I agree with Lampard though, he was the best midfielder in the world last this season.
 

Joystick

Deep like Titanic
10 August 2004
London
The Arse
Underrated:

Lampard
Robben
Terry
Joe Cole
Fabregas
Reyes (a bit)
Carragher
Xabi Alonso
Rooney
Pirlo
Xavi

Overrated:

Diouf
Kewell
Veron
Owen (a bit)
Saviola
most of Inter Milan, except Adriano
 

Interista

Il Capitano
19 August 2003
Bahrain
FC Internazionale
inter_211 said:
Who do you think is underrated and his stats should be improved in the new WE9 ?? and also who do you think was overrated and should have a stat-drop ?

for me:

Underrated- Robben, Lampard, Belleti, Forlan
Overrated- Diesler, Vieri(should lose speed)

Bymistake i kept Forlan in the overrated players :P (i edited it now)
he's really underrated, his speed shooting should become better, and other foot should be 8 or 7 !
 

Happy_2008

Non-League
17 December 2002
I think Rooney, Christiano Ronaldo and Giggs are quite underated. On the other hand for some strange reason, Gerrard stats are always crap :(
 

EatonTJ

Why Today Doesn't Suck.
Staff
11 April 2002
Every player is underrated. Ratings should be more like CM (where people can be physically great, but skillfully incompetent and visa-versa). While WE has gotten better in this area, there is still a lot of room to improve with player rating accuracy.
 

HBK

Non-League
20 January 2005
Underrated:
D.Berbatov
Martin Petrov
Stilian Petrov
Eto'o
Xavi
Oleguer
Overrated:
Nistelrooy
Ronaldo
Figo
Raul!
Kahn
Vieri
Larsson
....
 

Interista

Il Capitano
19 August 2003
Bahrain
FC Internazionale
foxtrot said:
Underrated:

Stefan Klos
Marcelinho
Marek Mintal

Overrated:

Obafemi Martins
Adrian Mutu
Yegor Titov
Michael Owen
I personally dont think Martins is overrated, all he has is pace and thats treu in real life, he's the fastest player alive, and his shots are crap in the game but if you look at his goals in real life, he scored some great goals from outside the box.
 

mattster12

All-round Bastard
11 April 2005
definetly not cristiano, think he means ronaldo of Real. Joe cole is another underated player. Infact nearly all of the chelsea team are underated, apart from drogba, he's just wank lol
 

OPM

...
2 June 2003
Budapest
.
foxtrot said:
I knew you would. :p
;) but not only because of mintal.klos surely is underrated, keeping excellent over years for the rangers but just not getting the attention in SPL.Marcelinho is a wonderful player that just hasn't got good enoughs tats cause he is not playing for the selecao.

And overrated guys:

Mutu hasn't played for ages, his stats need to drop.Owen is good, but he is waaay overrated.

and so on.

Hope Konami will improve their DB.
 

Mauras

Premiership
7 October 2002
Underrated players (which I remember):

Carvalho
Terry
Lampard
Robben
Garcia
Ronaldinho (already great but I think deserves more when compared to other pseudo-stars)
Deco
Eto
Cristiano Ronaldo (already cool but needs to be more explosive, as he is)
Dida (fails too much for a keeper who has saved Milan several times this year)


Overrated:
Beckham, Beckham, Beckham...
Veron
Recoba
Toldo (nice keeper but is a God in WE)
Vieri
Stam (he is great but WE always overrated him, has the power of an OX)

Underrated teams:
Chelsea
Barcelona
Lyon
Juventus (too efective in real life to be a second option in WE)

Overrated teams:
Real Madrid
Internazionale
 

gflare

Post Count?
20 July 2004
MD, USA
Chelsea
how can you say Ronaldo is underrated? He obliterates every defender unless it's Ferdinand, nesta or stam! And he gets his head on every cross into the box. I'd say his stats a just barely overrated, but definately not underrated.

Vieri's speed is overrated

underrated: Lampard and Pirlo
 

bulldrig

Conference
27 October 2001
EatonTJ said:
Every player is underrated. Ratings should be more like CM (where people can be physically great, but skillfully incompetent and visa-versa). While WE has gotten better in this area, there is still a lot of room to improve with player rating accuracy.
Good point, but while the stats may be more varied then before, the effect of these changes in skills is more non-existant than ever.

just getting back to more older versions here, latest game am playing about is we6, great game btw despite the annoying speed cheating. Anyhow, thing is you can really tell the difference between a skillful player and a lousy blonker. Getting the ball to a more skillful, quicker player, say Aimar, is a real relif compared to handling the ball with any given central defender. Its such a great sense of realism here.

With WE8:liveware it doesnt matter if you change about the different skill-parameters with 40 points, it makes little difference. Actually if anything, quicker players are extremely annoying in we8 since they are almost uncontrollable.
 

brunnoce

World Cup Winner
29 July 2003
Belo Horizonte, Brazil
Cruzeiro
Mauras said:
Underrated players (which I remember):

Carvalho
Terry
Lampard
Robben
Garcia
Ronaldinho (already great but I think deserves more when compared to other pseudo-stars)
Deco
Eto
Cristiano Ronaldo (already cool but needs to be more explosive, as he is)
Dida (fails too much for a keeper who has saved Milan several times this year)


Overrated:
Beckham, Beckham, Beckham...
Veron
Recoba
Toldo (nice keeper but is a God in WE)
Vieri
Stam (he is great but WE always overrated him, has the power of an OX)

Underrated teams:
Chelsea
Barcelona
Lyon
Juventus (too efective in real life to be a second option in WE)

Overrated teams:
Real Madrid
Internazionale
SIGN!

i must add KEWELL to the overratted players!!he must go down!!the guy plays like Garrincha in the game!! cmon..he hasnt done much now days!

and i must include Forlan, Sorin, Robinho, Robben, GOMES(PSV) and many others..but i would be here all day tipying...
oh this one deserves big improvement..JULIO BAPTISTA..the guy should have something close to 95-97 in balance...hes a bull! (LA BESTA!):mrgreen:
 
Last edited:

bummy_jab

League 2
9 August 2004
I think everyone here can agree that Peter Cech is the most underrated keeper in the game..... Everytime I play master league Chelsea never use him... he just rots in the bench every season.... The only time he plays is in normal league play because i fix the stats....... They really need to do sumthing about adjusting stats in master league because some players are extremely overrated like Kluivert or Dyer... they are like gods in master leage mode....
 

grechzoo

Conference
15 July 2004
north wales (uk)
anyone give me a carragher!!!!!! oh and alonso too, (althought he is decent already, his passing ability should be closer to what gerrards is and just for being so intelignt he should have oher stats improved.

rise maybe (all lfc i know) as he has had a great sason, other should be, wright phillips of course, defoe, carrick is a good player now, as is downing
 

HBK

Non-League
20 January 2005
I think that Puyol needs improvement too:)Baptista for sure.
and Juninho from Lyon !!he is so underrated.His free kick stats should be 100...
Overrated-Aimar?Di Vaio?
It will be good if there is an update every month,which can change player's stats due to their performances...or smthg like that;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom